Topic: [APPROVED] Minecraft Mobs BUR

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

user 1650047

Member

The bulk update request #8220 is active.

create implication zombie_(minecraft) (52) -> minecraft (8212)
create implication glow_squid_(minecraft) (27) -> minecraft (8212)
create alias glowsquid_(minecraft) (0) -> glow_squid_(minecraft) (27)
create implication guardian_(minecraft) (15) -> minecraft (8212)
create implication phantom_(minecraft) (42) -> minecraft (8212)
create implication strider_(minecraft) (7) -> minecraft (8212)
create implication witch_(minecraft) (8) -> minecraft (8212)
create alias wither_skeleton_(minecraft) (5) -> wither_skeleton (5)
create implication wither_skeleton (5) -> minecraft (8212)
create implication illager_(minecraft) (13) -> minecraft (8212)
create implication drowned_(minecraft) (8) -> minecraft (8212)
create implication husk_(minecraft) (2) -> minecraft (8212)
create implication wandering_trader_(minecraft) (7) -> minecraft (8212)
create implication magma_cube (26) -> minecraft (8212)
create implication tuff_golem_(minecraft) (3) -> golem_(minecraft) (74)
create implication snow_golem_(minecraft) (36) -> golem_(minecraft) (74)
create implication pillager_(minecraft) (8) -> illager_(minecraft) (13)
create implication evoker_(minecraft) (3) -> illager_(minecraft) (13)

Reason: Might as well do the easiest part now, implying species to the copyright they're from. I'm skipping over the animal_(minecraft) tags until it's decided what to do with them.

Wither skeletons really don't need a suffix. Tuff and snow golems are golems, and pillagers are illagers.

EDIT: The bulk update request #8220 (forum #405892) has been approved by @furrypickle.

Updated by auto moderator

user 1650047

Member

watsit said:
illager looks like an easy to make typo of villager. wandering_trader, magma_cube, and snow_golem also seem too generic without a suffix.

Suffixing illager wouldn't make it less of a problem in regards to villager, since there are also Minecraft villagers. But I'm not against suffixing it.

I really don't think magma cube needs a suffix, I'll edit the bur to suffix the other two + illager.

faucet

Member

watsit said:
illager looks like an easy to make typo of villager...

...why is this aliased to villager_(animal_crossing)? Doesn't seem to result in many mistags... but not a good idea nonetheless.

watsit said:
... wandering_trader, magma_cube, and snow_golem also seem too generic without a suffix.

In agreement here, those 3 things definitely exist in other places, to name a few:

user 1650047

Member

faucet said:
...why is this aliased to villager_(animal_crossing)? Doesn't seem to result in many mistags... but not a good idea nonetheless.

In agreement here, those 3 things definitely exist in other places, to name a few:

Do we really think Magma Slime is close enough to Magma Cube to cause an issue? They use completely different words and the other magma slimes aren't cube shaped so I'm not sure how they'd be ambiguous.

Wandering Spaniel

Janitor

nimphia said:
Do we really think Magma Slime is close enough to Magma Cube to cause an issue? They use completely different words and the other magma slimes aren't cube shaped so I'm not sure how they'd be ambiguous.

I really don't think it's an issue tbh. Same for illager

SNPtheCat

Member

The bulk update request #8226 is active.

remove alias villager (0) -> villager_(animal_crossing) (4579)

Reason: They don't have a monopoly on villagers, plan to disambiguate the tag next

alias villager -> villager_(disambiguation) category villager_(disambiguation) -> invalid

wandering_spaniel said:
I really don't think it's an issue tbh. Same for illager

+1

EDIT: The bulk update request #8226 (forum #405927) has been approved by @slyroon.

Updated by auto moderator

Donovan DMC

Former Staff

nimphia said:
Do we really think Magma Slime is close enough to Magma Cube to cause an issue? They use completely different words and the other magma slimes aren't cube shaped so I'm not sure how they'd be ambiguous.

Some people would definitely call minecraft's magma cubes magma slimes since they're practically the same but in different dimensions, same attack and splitting behavior

user 1650047

Member

donovan_dmc said:
Some people would definitely call minecraft's magma cubes magma slimes since they're practically the same but in different dimensions, same attack and splitting behavior

That's just regular old mistagging, though, since that's not their name :P

Also I have no idea what the downvote's for. That user has no forum posts.