Topic: Tag alias: holding_in_urine -> omorashi

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The tag alias #82316 holding_in_urine -> omorashi is pending approval.

Reason: Just stumbled across a dubious tag, holding_in_urine, at 65 posts. "Omorashi" is literally just desperation from holding in (or failing to hold in) urine, and if the character isn't "desperate", then why would holding_in_urine even be tagged in the first place? To be fair, there actually ARE three posts tagged holding_in_urine where a character doesn't seem desperate and says they've been holding it in*, but does that really justify keeping this tag? At best, the tag could use a wiki clarifying what it's for, if we decide to keep it.

*In all cases, the character said they were holding off so they could relieve themself in another character.

It might be worth mentioning that the "omorashi" vs. "pee_desperation" tag name debate is still unresolved (topic #44534), so that might need to be resolved first anyways, so we know which to alias holding_in_urine to (if we decide to alias it away).

Omorashi is specifically a fetish, and holding in urine is not necessarily always depicted in a fetish context. Although, how would you determine through TWYS if it's innocent or not? Omorashi is not a very TWYS friendly tag when you consider that.
post #1663262

There are a whole lot of duplicate tags like this, where one tag is the 'fetish name' for something and another is a 'neutral' description of the exact same thing.

I say alias it, TWYS means we don't care about 'intent' and it's very annoying to have to search for both in situations like that